This is G o o g l e's cache of http://groups.google.com/group/sci.med.cardiology/msg/ddb25eb1d5cf468a as retrieved on Oct 22, 2006 21:42:03 GMT.
G o o g l e's cache is the snapshot that we took of the page as we crawled the web.
The page may have changed since that time. Click here for the current page without highlighting.
This cached page may reference images which are no longer available. Click here for the cached text only.
To link to or bookmark this page, use the following url: http://www.google.com/custom?q=cache:zA_J__zUO_AJ:groups.google.com/group/sci.med.cardiology/msg/ddb25eb1d5cf468a+ddb25eb1d5cf468a&hl=en&gl=us&ct=clnk&cd=1
These terms only appear in links pointing to this page: ddb25eb1d5cf468a

Google Groups: sci.med.cardiology
Groups Home | Help | Sign in
Go to Google Groups Home   
Web    Images    Video    News    Maps    more »
  Advanced Groups Search
  Preferences
sci.med.cardiology > Man-made orthodox doctrine like other things man-made fall short of GOD's glory.
Fixed font - Proportional font
From: Andrew B. Chung, MD/PhD - view profile
Date: Thurs, Aug 24 2006 4:07 am
Email: "Andrew B. Chung, MD/PhD" <nosp...@heartmdphd.com>
Groups: sci.med.cardiology, alt.christnet.christianlife, alt.religion.clergy, alt.christnet.evangelical
Not yet rated
Rating:
 
show options

Chuck Stamford wrote:
> "Andrew B. Chung, MD/PhD" <nosp...@heartmdphd.com> wrote in message
> news:1156319025.986679.159640@m73g2000cwd.googlegroups.com...
> > Chuck Stamford wrote:
> >> "Andrew B. Chung, MD/PhD" <nosp...@heartmdphd.com> wrote in message
> >> news:1156311142.162277.95880@m73g2000cwd.googlegroups.com...
> >> > Chuck Stamford wrote:
> >> >> <calvi...@sysko.com> wrote in message
> >> >> news:44e9c7e4$0$24656$1c4686b2@selenium.club.cc.cmu.edu...
> >> >> > When it was mentioned that three false doctrines were being taught
> >> >> > we
> >> >> > got the response:

> >> >> > "Your bearing false witness against me is forgiven as far as I am
> >> >> > concerned."

> >> >> > If he now wants to turn away from the false doctrines then it can be
> >> >> > said it was false witness.  If he continues in the false doctrines
> >> >> > then
> >> >> > it is not.  The measure as it has always been is the 2000 years of
> >> >> > orthodox teaching on the topics of the false doctrines, it is not my
> >> >> > opinions that matter.  When using self reference alone lone ranger
> >> >> > bible
> >> >> > interpretation will almost always be false with out the correction
> >> >> > of a
> >> >> > communion of christians, such is what we find here.

> >> >> > The love and blessing and protection and peace of God upon you.  If
> >> >> > we
> >> >> > confess our sins He is quick to forgive them, very true; amen.

> >> >> Are you sure you're not just trying to stir up trouble by making a
> >> >> mountain
> >> >> out of a mole hill?

> >> > There are those who wish to believe they will know GOD through orthodox
> >> > doctrine rather than through HIS Word with the counsel of the Holy
> >> > Spirit.

> >> >> And just out of curiosity, what *do* the "communion of christians
> >> >> [sic]"
> >> >> (who I guess must have sent you here as their representative) think
> >> >> Jesus
> >> >> was teaching us with His cursing of the fig tree?

> >> > Orthodox doctrine which is man-made and not GOD-breathed has no
> >> > explanation for why Christ Jesus cursed the fig tree for not bearing
> >> > figs out-of-season (Mark 11:12-14) nor for why the tree was found the
> >> > next morning withered to its roots (Mark 11:20).

> >> > Since the Holy Spirit has given me the understanding that the fig tree
> >> > sinned against GOD by refusing to bear fruit for LORD Jesus Christ, the
> >> > thought of figs has been on my mind.  In all my life, I have never
> >> > eaten figs and I wondered how they tasted.  Today without my asking her
> >> > (did not know that she even had a fig tree), a patient brought me 4
> >> > figs from her tree (uncommon in Atlanta). She said this was the first
> >> > time her tree had borne fruit and that she remembered my telling her to
> >> > share whenever she had more food than she should eat and was moved to
> >> > choose me to be the recipient of the extra harvest. These figs added to
> >> > my lunch would have made my noon-time meal inordinately large at 15
> >> > ounces so I gave 2 to my office manager reducing the meal to a more
> >> > reasonable 12 ounces.  The figs were delicious ! !   Most assuredly
> >> > without doubt GOD reads our minds and is sovereign over all things.

> >> > Amen !

> >> On all but the part about the tree sinning.  You know, it doesn't
> >> necessarily follow from the fact that all creation "groans" under the
> >> curse
> >> of God against the sin of Adam, that all of creation sins.

> > Correct.  Sin arises from choice made through the free will generously
> > given by GOD to the soul.

> >> It's entirely
> >> possible for something to be affected by the actions of another without
> >> that
> >> thing being a culpable party to that action.

> > Correct.

> >> And it's entirely possible
> >> that that poor little fig tree wasn't producing any fruit, not because of
> >> its own sin, but because of the sin of Adam, whom God had (before his sin
> >> and fall from grace) given dominion over His creation.

> > It is through the original sin of Adam and Eve that a sinful nature was
> > conferred to the souls of everything that GOD created in this world.

> So what does "soul" mean as you're using it here, Andrew?

The same soul/spirit as described in the Holy Bible:

"But if from there you seek the LORD your God, you will find HIM if you
look for HIM with all your heart and with all your soul." (Deut 4:29)

"Love the LORD your God with all your heart and with all your soul and
with all your strength." (Deut 6:5)

"The LORD your God is testing you to find out whether you love HIM with
all your heart and with all your soul." (Deut 13:3)

"The LORD your God will circumcise your hearts and the hearts of your
descendants, so that you may love HIM with all your heart and with all
your soul, and live."(Deut 30:6)

"...to preserve his soul from the pit, his life from perishing by the
sword." (Job 33:18)

"HE redeemed my soul from going down to the pit, and I will live to
enjoy the light." (Job 33:28)

"The LORD examines the righteous, but the wicked and those who love
violence HIS soul hates." (Psalm 11:5)

"To you, O LORD, I lift up my soul" (Psalm 25:1)

"As the deer pants for streams of water, so my soul pants for you, O
GOD." (Psalm 42:1)

"My soul thirsts for GOD, for the living GOD. When can I go and meet
with GOD?" (Psalm 42:2)

"O GOD, you are my GOD, earnestly I seek YOU; my soul thirsts for YOU,
my body longs for YOU, in a dry and weary land where there is no
water." (Psalm 63:1)

"I spread out my hands to YOU; my soul thirsts for YOU like a parched
land." (Psalm 143:6)

"The fruit of the righteous is a tree of life, and he who wins souls is
wise." (Proverbs 11:30)

"For every living soul belongs to ME, the father as well as the
son-both alike belong to ME. The soul who sins is the one who will
die." (Ezek 18:4)

"Do not be afraid of those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul.
Rather, be afraid of the ONE Who can destroy both soul and body in
hell." (Matt 10:28)

"What good will it be for a man if he gains the whole world, yet
forfeits his soul? Or what can a man give in exchange for his soul?"
(Matt 16:26)

"For you were like sheep going astray, but now you have returned to the
Shepherd and Overseer of your souls." (1 Peter 2:25)

"When HE opened the fifth seal, I saw under the altar the souls of
those who had been slain because of the word of GOD and the testimony
they had maintained." (Rev 6:9)

"I saw thrones on which were seated those who had been given authority
to judge. And I saw the souls of those who had been beheaded because of
their testimony for Jesus and because of the word of GOD. They had not
worshiped the beast or his image and had not received his mark on their
foreheads or their hands. They came to life and reigned with Christ a
thousand years." (Rev 20:4)

> I take it to mean
> the sum of our cognitive faculties; our faculties of perception, reasoning,
> memory, sympathy, testimony, and something Calvin called the "sensus
> divinitus"; that faculty in us the Holy Spirit of God uses to communicate
> with us.  (And I don't mean by "faculty" something material in this
> instance.  I mean, taking "perception" as the example here, the perceptual
> "beliefs" we form, or perhaps even more explicitly, have delivered to us by
> this perceptual faculty, on having our visual apparatus stimulated)

See above.

Clearly the soul is much more.

> So as I understand soul, at a minimum, it takes a "person" to have one;
> understanding that at a minimum a "person" is a being possessed of "mind",
> "will", and "emotion".  So, by extenstion, I believe that only "persons" are
> capable of making cognitive choices, and to "sin" takes, at a bear minimum,
> making a cognitive choice.

The understanding given to me by the Holy Spirit is that GOD has placed
souls in everything HE commands.

> > Prior to the original sin, only the serpent satan in the garden of Eden
> > had a sinful nature (Genesis 3:1 and Revelation 12:9).

> I don't think he was the "only" one.  Scripture tells us of a "war" that
> took place in heaven when Satan fell from grace, and that he took a "third"
> of all the angels God created with him in that war, which resulted in all of
> them being cast out of heaven.  Now I take these stories to be true, but I
> also take them to be metaphorical to some degree.  So I'm not sure I take
> the "war" literally, but I take Satan and his angels being cast out of
> heaven literally in the sense that their state of being before God was
> irrevocably changed and damaged beyond repair, even for God.  The point
> being that when Satan entered the Garden as the serpent, more persons
> (angels being "persons") than just him had sinned against God...and we have
> God's word for that.

The other fallen beings were not in the garden of Eden.

> > The tree of knowledge of good and evil standing in the middle of the
> > garden was a fig tree and was the source of the leaves that Adam and
> > Eve used to make coverings for themselves (Genesis 3:7).

> Andrew, the text doesn't tell us that the tree of the knowledge of good and
> evil was a fig tree

Correct.  This understanding was "sealed" so that people would not
automatically believe that either the fig tree or its figs were to be
avoided.

>, nor does it tell us that the fig leaves Adam and Eve
> sewed together to cover their "nakedness" after their sin came from that
> tree.

Correct.  This is part of the "seal."

> What you're doing here is working off an inference from the text, not
> the text itself.

In truth, this is an understanding from the Holy Spirit.

> > It was not by chance that a fig tree sinned against GOD here.

> How is it possible, even if the tree of the knowledge of good and evil were
> a fig tree, that it sinned?

It had a soul and free will.

> What did it *do*, Andrew, except be what God created it to be?

GOD did not want Adam and Eve to fall from HIS grace by disobeying and
sinning against HIM.  The fig tree willfully played along with satan's
deception of Eve.

It could have chosen not to bear fruit for Eve just as its descendant
chose not to bear fruit for LORD Jesus Christ (Mark 11:12-14).

> It didn't engage in some act contrary to its Divine
> design.  It was just there, standing in the middle of the Garden exactly
> where God placed it when He created it, being what God intended it to be: an
> alternative for Adam and Eve that gave to them the potential to exercise
> *their* free will and make a choice either to obey God or disobey.

See above.

> I would suggest to you that it was God's *command* to Adam not to eat of it
> that made eating of it sinful;

Correct.

> not that the tree, in and of itself, was
> sinful, or had committed any sin against its Creator.

The tree was a willing participant in deceiving Eve.

> The tree came
> straight from God who is perfectly holy, and did nothing but what God
> intended in creating it.

The tree willfully did nothing to keep Eve from being deceived by
satan.

Such is the sin of omission.

> If our premise is that it is sinful, then we have
> to find some way of avoiding that it's sinfulness was created *in it* by
> God, and to do that we would need to identify some act of the tree contrary
> to the will of it's Creator in the text...and there just isn't any that I
> can find.

See above.  The sinful nature of the forbidden tree would not be fully
revealed until LORD Jesus Christ cursed its descendant fig tree as
described in Mark 11.

> I would also suggest to you that there is nothing inherently sinful about
> the knowledge of good and evil.

The knowledge of good and evil without omniscience is incomplete and
harmful as was demonstrated in Adam and Eve..

> There can't be, because God is omniscient,
> which means God surely must have this knowledge, and God certainly isn't
> sinning against Himself by having it.

Omniscience, which is complete knowledge, is holy, which is by
definition without sin.

> > Indeed, there is no such thing as chance (Proverbs 16:33).

> You get a big "Amen" to that!  I'd only qualify it by adding that I don't
> believe God's creation is completely deterministic in nature, because if it
> were, free will would be an illusion, and I don't accept that free will is
> an illusion anymore than I accept that sin is an illusion.

Thought is separate from its actuation.  The former arises from our
respective free wills and the latter is controlled by GOD's infinite
free will.  It is the latter that is being described in Proverbs 16:33.

> People who
> commit sin may be said to be suffering under an "illusion" when they do, but
> the sin itself is absolutely real.

...even when GOD does not permit the sinful thought to become action.

> >> So just as Adam's
> >> sin rebounds to us because we all come "out of" Adam, so to it rebounds
> >> to
> >> all creation because all creation was under Adam's dominion when he
> >> sinned.

> > See above.

> They say that if you get Genesis right, the rest of biblical theology comes
> much easier.  Here's a passage from Genesis I'd like you to give some
> thought, and then tell me what it means to you.

> Then God blessed them [Adam and Eve], and God said to them, "Be fruitful and
> multiply; fill the earth and subdue it; have dominion over the fish of the
> sea, over the birds of the air, and over every living thing that moves on
> the earth." 29 And God said, "See, I have given you every herb that yields
> seed which is on the face of all the earth, and every tree whose fruit
> yields seed; to you it shall be for food. 30 "Also, to every beast of the
> earth, to every bird of the air, and to everything that creeps on the earth,
> in which there is life, I have given every green herb for food"; and it was
> so. Gen 1:28-30 (NKJV - "Adam and Eve" aren't in the text, but for any
> casual readers who might read this post, they are who God is speaking to in
> the text, so I've inserted their names in brackets to denote that fact)

> I take it that what is being said here is very important, for in a chapter
> that runs only 31 verses, and summarizes God creation of *everything* that
> He created, three of those verses are used to express this message!  That's
> 10% of the text that deals with all of creation spent to tell us whatever
> it's telling us.  I'd like to know what you think it's telling us, and why
> it's given this much attention in God's word.

These verses tell us of HIS love for us. They tell us how HE has shown
HIS love for us with the showering of gifts upon HIS beloved though we
have sinned against HIM.  Our GOD loves us so very much (John 3:16).

> >> In any case, if Genesis teaches us nothing else about "sin", it teaches
> >> us
> >> that sinning (just as "loving") requires making a morally significant and
> >> uncoerced choice.

> > GOD's choice to give HIS generous gift of free will while retaining HIS
> > infinite will speaks to HIS infinite glory.

> Yes it certainly does.  But it also means there are truths here that are
> true because they are contingent upon God having given the marvelous gift of
> free will, and one of those contingent truths is that God gives that gift
> only to persons (i.e., to *be* a "person", a being must possess free will as
> an essential property, by definition), which entails that only a person can
> sin, because sin requires not only that a person possess (as God's gift)
> free will, but exercise it; make a choice; albeit a poor one, since we are
> talking about sinning.

Would have your remember that it is written that Christ Jesus has
informed us that the stones would cry out to praise HIM if we were to
fall silent.

These are related to the stones in the desert that could have been
commanded by HIM to turn to bread.

The mountains can be commanded by HIM to jump into the sea.

The storm clouds were commanded by HIM to disperse and they obeyed !

The fish was commanded to swallow a gold coin and be caught by HIS
disciples in order to be brought to HIM to pay the temple tax and it
obeyed !

May GOD continue to heal our hearts, dear brother Chuck whom I love
unconditionally.

Prayerfully in Christ's amazing love,

Andrew <><
--
Andrew B. Chung
Cardiologist, Atlanta, Georgia, USA
http://HeartMDPhD.com/HolySpirit

As for knowing who are the very elect, these you will know by the
unconditional love they have for everyone including their enemies
(Matthew 5:44-45, 1 Corinthians 13:3, James 2:14-17).

http://groups.google.com/group/sci.med.cardiology/msg/d3b7b57d0fbf89ed?


Google Home - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy

©2006 Google